Protein or Carbohydrates?

This has got to be the biggest controversy in modern bodybuilding. Bodybuilders will say you've got to consume loads of protein to pack on quality muscle mass and increase strength. Nutrition experts say that you must eat a high carbohydrate diet, particularly complex carbs, to improve strength and size, and say that a high protein is of no benefit.

Who is right? You could say both are right. Only a few studies have been carried out looking into high protein intake and improvements in strength and muscle size. The results are inconclusive. Study design was poor, often only having very few subjects, who may be over-training or under-training. Other aspects of diet were often overlooked and most were only carried out on novice weight trainers who may not know how to train correctly. Also, the topic of anabolic steroids is avoided which does increase demand for protein.

Protein

Muscle consists mainly of two proteins, actin and myosin. The turnover rate of amino acids in these proteins is high, and increases upon stimulation such as exercise. If the muscle is worked to maximum effort like during a correctly executed bodybuilding workout, turnover is extremely high. Hence, there is a large demand from the body's pool of amino acids. High carb fans say this demand can be met by only a moderately higher than normal protein intake. High protein fans argue very high levels of protein are needed to meet demand. Bodybuilders who have plateaued in their gains for long periods, have dramatically increased their protein intake and started making gains. Also anabolic steroids increase the rate of protein synthesis within muscle cells, further increasing demand for protein.

Carbohydrate

The argument for a high carb intake comes from the fact that we need energy to fuel our workouts and to recuperate and grow. This is certainly the case for athletes who may need as much as 60% of their energy intake from carbs. High carb advocates also say that a "normal" intake of high protein foods should be eaten, as starchy carbohydrate foods also contain some protein, which will increase protein intake sufficiently. The type of carbs that should be consumed is high fiber starchy ones like whole meal bread, brown rice, whole wheat breakfast cereals, etc.

Using Both Protein and Carbs

Dietitians and nutritionists too often look at the percentage of total energy intake for proteins and carbohydrates. It would be better to look at actual intake levels. Both protein and carbs are needed in high amounts in order to gain muscle for all the reasons discussed above.

The problem in giving general advice is that we are individuals and therefore our requirements for different nutrients vary. If you are trying to gain muscle at the same time as trying to lose body fat, your carbohydrate intake will need to be reduced. If you are a beginner bodybuilder who is very skinny, your protein intake will need to be high and you will need to consume high carb foods regularly to gain weight.

Remember, you will not make good gains unless your protein intake is sufficient. Any successful bodybuilder will tell you this, no matter what so-called experts say and clinical trials show. A reasonably high intake of quality carbs is also required to train on and for recuperation. Eat complex carbs regularly throughout the day.

It is hard to give you figures of how much is required, as we are all so different. But as a general rule for any bodybuilder who is trying to gain muscle size and strength and does not wish to gain bodyfat, the following would be a good guide:

Protein: 1.0-1.5g of protein per pound bodyweight, depending on whether you use anabolic steroids. The intake must be staggered throughout the day at regular intervals.

Carbohydrate: Approximately 2g per pound bodyweight, and eat regularly through the day. As well as the above, remember to eat a balanced healthy diet, which is reasonably low in fat and high in fruit and vegetables.

Jeffrey Bedeaux

Your guide to building muscle and getting fit. http://www.dr-natural-bodybuilding.com

Over the past 16 years I have read 100's of magazines, almost 100 books, attended about a dozen seminars and consumed any other type of information on the topic of bodybuilding to advance my knowledge in this area. I also have a Bachelors of Science degree in Biochemistry with minors in Chemistry and Microbiology from Colorado State University, 1998.

Related News

Get moving: Guidelines set healthy activity levels - The Associated Press Get moving: Guidelines set healthy activity levels The Associated Press -11 hours ago _Adults should do muscle-strengthening activities — push-ups, weight training, carrying heavy loads or heavy gardening — at least two days a week. ... New Muscle Building Program Delivers Elite Level Muscle Gains - PR Web (press release) PR Web (press release) New Muscle Building Program Delivers Elite Level Muscle Gains PR Web (press release), WA -Sep 25, 2008 The launch of the Athletic Muscle Building program brings the secret training programs of elite athletes to everyone trying to gain muscle. ... Weight Loss Through Protein Bars - Times of the Internet Weight Loss Through Protein Bars Times of the Internet, Ohio -Oct 4, 2008 Protein has amazing effects on the human body and the concentrated protein you can get from protein bars is useful in helping you build muscle. ... Muscle Building Exercises to Build Muscle - Times of the Internet Muscle Building Exercises to Build Muscle Times of the Internet, Ohio -Sep 14, 2008 No longer will it be troublesome to take a quick jog, or to rush up a flight of stairs, not with all the different kinds of muscle building exercises to be ... Take the tube - Calgary Herald Take the tube Calgary Herald,  Canada -Oct 2, 2008 The latest news confirms what many fitness experts have advocated for years: novice exercisers don't need a gym full of equipment to build muscle. ... Motivation Monday: Chris opens the Motivation Mailbag - KARE Motivation Monday: Chris opens the Motivation Mailbag KARE, MN -Oct 6, 2008 I hear all the time that women need to build muscle to increase their metabolism, but I'm afraid of bulking up. Will free weights make me bigger? ... Shrewd Moves by Red Sox Are on Display in Postseason - New York Times New York Times Shrewd Moves by Red Sox Are on Display in Postseason New York Times, United States -14 hours ago Because Beckett was hampered by a strained oblique muscle, Lester replaced him in the opener, did not allow an earned run and won. ... Jefferson West High School Wins National got milk?(R) Refuel Your ... - MarketWatch Jefferson West High School Wins National got milk?(R) Refuel Your ... MarketWatch -Oct 6, 2008 Milk contains nine essential nutrients, including calcium and vitamin D to maintain bone strength, and high-quality protein that helps build muscle when ... Why men lose weight faster than women - Dallas Morning News Why men lose weight faster than women Dallas Morning News, TX -Oct 6, 2008 This helps build muscle mass, she says, so women can take advantage of the metabolic boost. "Weights are good," she says. "Another way is with stability ... Try a supplement with multivitamin - Chicago Sun-Times Try a supplement with multivitamin Chicago Sun-Times, United States -21 hours ago Q. If I take supplements to help build muscle, do I urinate out what I don't need? A trainer told me that the body can only assimilate so much and that ...